I Was This Close to Leasing a Horse with Three Names and No Shoes (A Cautionary Tale… and a Better Way to Shop Smarter)
Ever tried to lease a horse through Facebook messages, mismatched photos, and ghosted PPEs? Same. Here’s what happened — and how it led me to a smarter way to horse shop (and keep my sanity).
By Neighh Team ·
It started, as these stories always do, with a blurry photo and a message that read:
“She’s green but sweet. Just needs finishing. Sometimes pins her ears. Might be in heat.”
So naturally, I was intrigued.
I had been casually (read: obsessively) scrolling every Facebook group and local barn bulletin board, trying to find the one. The right lease. The right match. The horse who wouldn’t eat my wallet or throw me into next week.
This particular mare had three names, no shoes, and one half-written ad from a seller who preferred voice memos over full sentences. What followed was a whirlwind of:
Conflicting answers
Cancelled trial rides
A last-minute “actually she might be sold” text
And a PPE where the vet wrapped her hoof in duct tape “just to get a reading”
Spoiler alert: I didn’t lease the horse. But I did learn a few things.
🌀 The Wild West of Horse Shopping
Buying or leasing a horse through Facebook and word of mouth can work. It also can feel like Craigslist meets Catfish — with a dash of Venmo panic.
Between unverified sellers, confusing logistics, ghosted messages, and that classic “forgot to mention she cribs” surprise — it’s a lot.
And for those of us trying to shop while juggling life, jobs, kids, or just basic sanity… it can be too much.
🔎 What I Really Wanted
One place to browse
Real listings with clear details
Photos that didn’t look like they were taken on a Motorola Razr
Messaging that didn’t involve screenshots
The ability to feel like an actual buyer — not a detective
🐴 What I Found Instead: Neighh
Somewhere around my 14th Facebook message that started with “Is this horse still available?” and ended in silence, a friend sent me a link to Neighh.
The vibe? Clean. Modern. Created by riders. No chaos. No confusion.
No horses named “Misty’s Storm aka Bella aka Socks.”
There were filters that made sense:
Discipline. Height. PPE-friendly? Lease or Sale?
The listings were honest. Some even charming. And everything felt… normal. Refreshing, even.
🧭 Neighh Isn’t Magic (Yet)… But It’s a Start
Let’s be real: there aren’t thousands of horses on Neighh right now. It's brand new — just like I was, when I came back to riding after a decade off. But the foundation is there.
It’s clean, secure, and thoughtfully built.
It’s not trying to sell you an algorithm or hide contact info.
It’s built by people who get what this process is like — and believe it can be better.
🐴 Why I’m Glad I Signed Up Anyway
Neighh isn’t just a marketplace — it’s a movement.
It says: yes, let’s bring clarity to horse shopping.
Let’s prioritize horses’ wellbeing and humans’ sanity.
Let’s do things differently — and better.
Whether you're listing your horse or just browsing to dream a little, it’s a space made for us. And we get to help shape it.
🎯 Final Takeaway
If you’re stuck in the Facebook loop, chasing ghost listings and screenshots of horses with questionable backs and too many names — this is your sign.
Sign up. Make a profile. Start fresh.
Neighh isn’t full yet — but maybe that’s exactly the point. It’s a space waiting for people like you to make it better.
👉 Create your Neighh account today — for free.
Because leasing a horse shouldn’t feel like a true crime podcast.
Tags: horse shopping, lease a horse, horse buying mistakes, equestrian humor, horse lease gone wrong, how to buy a horse, online horse listings, Neighh blog, horse classifieds, horse buyer tips